Alan sokal is an icon for bad science hunters the world over, the man who pulled off the greatest academic scam of our times, and gave postmodernist. Physicist alan sokal revealed that his paper in social text was a parody on the abuse of science in the humanities invaded by irrationalist tendencies. He is best known for his criticism of postmodernism, which implies strongly that the proverbial emperor of postmodernism may indeed have been naked all along. Immediately afterwards he revealed the paper to be an elaborate hoax engineered to expose the bankruptcy of postmodernist discourse about science.
According to wikipedia, when sokal revealed his hoax, the editors didnt believe him and thought sokals admission represented a change of heart, or a folding of his. The academic left and its quarrels with science, by paul gross and norman levitt 1994, sokal tried an experiment. Science, philosophy, and culture is a 2008 book by alan sokal detailing the history of the sokal affair in which he submitted an article full of nonsense to a journal and was able to get it published reception. The sokal affair, also called the sokal hoax, was a demonstrative scholarly hoax performed by alan sokal, a physics professor at new york university and. New york university banner hangs from a building in new york in april 2010. At once outrageous and absurdist, his article transgressing the boundaries. He is a critic of postmodernism, and caused the sokal affair in 1996 when his deliberately nonsensical paper was published by duke university presss social text. The times writes that sokals essaysand his hoaxachieve their purpose of reminding us all that, in the words of the victorian mathematicianphilosopher. The book introduces an idea central to all of michaels work the consequences to consciousness and society of ancestral trauma, and how this underlying trauma becomes the means for slavethink and mass control. The editors of social text did not detect that sokals article was a hoax, and they published it in the journals springsummer 1996 issue.
After the article was published, sokal revealed his ruse and argued that academia was overtaken by a bunch of postmodern scholars who were critical of science, despite the. The paper argued that quantum gravity was a social construct. The sokal affair, also called the sokal hoax, was a demonstrative scholarly hoax performed by alan sokal, a physics professor at new york university and university college london. The sokal affair also sokals hoax was a hoax by physicist alan sokal perpetrated on the editorial staff and readership of the postmodern cultural studies journal social text published by duke university press. The sham that shook the academy by the editors of lingua franca. But there is one criticism that i have of the book. The sokal hoax was a whole theater of operations in the culture wars of the mid 90s, but my undergraduate students, who were in elementary school in the mid 90s, have to take my word the early debates are bitter exchanges of theory and charges of political unorthodoxy. In 1996, sokal submitted an article to social text, an academic journal of postmodern cultural studies. The sokal hoax became frontpage news around the world and triggered fierce and wideranging convtroversy for an article that was published in a culturalstudies journal was swiftly revealed by its author, alan sokal, to be a cunningly worded parody of extreme postmodernist criticism of science. He came to prominence for the eponymous sokal hoax.
The sokal affair, also called the sokal hoax, was a publishing hoax perpetrated by alan sokal, a physics professor at new york university. Alan sokal is an american physicist and mathematician. The sokal hoax shares with other controversies of our time the typical feature of erupting suddenly with the threat of dire consequence, only to disappear quickly and nearly completely from public consciousness. A universalistic citation pattern appears even in alan sokals famous hoax article, where some of his citing was deliberately particularistic. Anyone interested in the culture wars, the science wars, or american academia should be familiar with this material. Gender studies and the hoax paper wiley online library. Generally speaking, the journals that fell for sokal squared publish respected scholars from respected programs. The sokal hoax, also known as the sokal affair, was a publishing hoax perpetrated by alan sokal, a physics professor at new york university. I had enjoyed the hoax that made sokal famous outside his area of quantum. Beyond the hoax science, philosophy and culture alan sokal. Postmodern gravity deconstructed, slyly the new york times.
Sokal polish, sokal ukranian, russian, sikal yiddish, skol german, skul sokal, where the katz branch of my family originally came from, including my mother, grandfather and greatgrandfather background. Towards a transformative hermeneutics of quantum gravity att korsa granserna. Hoaxes of exposure are semicomical or private sting operations. In may 1996, a scandal erupted in united states academia. The reasons they give are various, but the ultimate justification for most religious peoples beliefs is a simple one. Science seeks truth, although, as the sokal hoax exposes, this is a truth not universally acknowledged in the humanities. Sokal in 1996 on the editors of the journal social text quickly became widely known and. In 1996, alan sokal, a professor of physics at new york university, wrote a paper for the culturalstudies journal social text, entitled transgressing the boundaries. But on what grounds can believers presume to know that these assertions are true. The book is a collection of essays he has written on the topic. Read derridas response to the sokal affair critical.
Sokal said he spent months editing the piece and showed it to numerous. In nursing, the doctrine of evidencebased practice depends on the quality of evidence, and research findings or theoretical argument should not be accepted. In 1996, physicist alan sokal perpetrated one of the few successful trojan horse rhetorical strategies in academia by submitting a fake article to a real academic journal, social text. I was reading about the sokal and wanted to share this. York university, submitted a paper transgressing the.
The submission was an experiment to test the journals intellectual rigor and, specifically, to investigate whether a leading north american journal of. The hilarious hoax that should have taught the academy a. That spring, social text accepted sokal s submission, and on may 15, sokal sent a. The submission was an experiment to test the journals intellectual rigor and, specifically, to investigate. Pdf a citation identity is a list of an authors citees ranked by how frequently that author has cited them in publications covered by the institute. So he submitted a bogus paper called transgressing the boundaries. Sokal immediately confessed that the whole article was a hoax a cunningly worded paper designed to expose and parody the style. In the united states, over twenty public forums devoted to the topic have either taken place or are scheduled, including packed sessions at princeton, duke, the. Sokals hoax may join the small company of legendary academic hoaxes, along with the pseudofossils of piltdown man planted by charles dawson and the pseudoceltic epic ossian written by james macpherson. The book was published in french in 1997, and in english in 1998. Hereafter referred to parenthetically in the text as r. For example, gender, place and culture, which accepted one of the hoax papers, has in the past months published work from professors at ucla, temple, penn state, trinity college dublin.
The fallibility of human reason in everyday life new york. It is now two years since alan sokal published the article transgressing boundaries. Towards a transformative hermeneutics of quantum gravity to social text, a journal in cultural studies. I had no idea when this special issue would be published, and the hoax had to be kept secret. In 1996, american physicist alan sokal submitted a paper loaded with nonsensical jargon to the journal social text, in which he argued that quantum gravity is a social and. He works in statistical mechanics and combinatorics. It is a rambling essay, filled with gender studies jargon, which took issue with the implications for trans and genderqueer individuals in regarding the penis. In 1994, alan sokal, a theoretical physicist from new. That spring, social text accepted sokals submission, and on may 15, sokal sent a.
Full text of the sokal hoax see other formats 1 morten tolboll the sokal hoax the sokal hoax, also known as the sokal affair, was a publishing hoax perpetrated by alan sokal, a physics professor at new york university. A study in citation identities article pdf available in scientometrics 601. The sokal hoax was about hubris the washington post. Below, we present a thoughtful reflection by alan sokal on the latest academic hoax perpetrated by james lindsay and peter boghossian, who managed to get. Each religion makes scores of purportedly factual assertions about everything from the creation of the universe to the afterlife. Featuring clifford goldstein this work is licensed under the creative commons attributionnoncommercialno derivative works 3. The sokal hoax remains a defining event in late20th century american academia, and this collection, along with sokals fashionable nonsense, is part of the essential documentation of this sad and sorry affair.
In 1996, new york university professor of physics alan sokal wrote a parody of an academic article he titled transgressing the boundaries. Sokals paper was read by the journal editors who both failed to recognize its absurdity and didnt even bother to check if he was pulling fake math jargon out of his ass. Towards a transformative hermeneutics of quantum gravity. Beyond the hoax alan sokal oxford university press. In 1996, sokal, a professor of physics at new york university, submitted a paper for publication in social text, as an experiment to see if a journal in that field would, in sokals. What the new sokal hoax reveals about academia the atlantic. While my method was satirical, my motivation was utterly. Postmodern intellectuals abuse of science, published in the uk as intellectual impostures, is a book by physicists alan sokal and jean bricmont. Similarly, the sokal hoax is a great example of bad faith used to justify an ideological position through point scoring rather than legitimate criticism. Toward a transformative hermeneutics of quantum gravity in the postmodern journal social text. The submission was an experiment to test the journals intellectual rigor, and specifically, to investigate. Beyond the hoax by alan sokal nicholas lezard on the wit and wisdom of transgression nicholas lezard. Next, these authors would publish in some journal called cosmic newsand claim that a naturalscience journal has fallen for their hoax. Sokal hoax a physicist experiments with cultural studies by alan sokal physicist alan sokal reveals the motivations behind his infamous sokal hoax article an experiment after becoming frustrated with what he saw as the abuses of science and mathematics by writers and academics under the umbrella of cultural studiespoststructuralism.
Eleven of the greatest scientific hoaxes new scientist. Sokal is best known for the sokal affair, in which he submitted a deliberately absurd article to social text, a critical theory journal, and was able to get it published. In fact, sokals basic adherence to universalism probably helped his hoax succeed, which suggests the strength of the mertonian norm. There is a lot of good and clear thinking in this book. In 1996, physicist alan sokal was unhappy with the tendency in academic postmodernism to dismiss scientific work. Papers by alan sokal on the social text affair sokalbricmont book. August 14, 1945 october 30, 2004 was a russianborn jewishamerican historian of science quotes the sokal hoax.
918 448 446 268 352 1264 1118 718 416 1275 959 245 913 1227 1302 426 1031 713 1225 1526 1251 58 80 1426 423 99 170 1219 1324 611 594 1099